Sony has beaten a UK-based class action lawsuit valued at around $2.6 billion. The lawsuit alleged that the company was using its “near monopoly” on the sale of digital games to impose unfair pricing practices. Representing consumers in the lawsuit is Alex Neill, who noted that the company is able to set strict terms about what can be sold on the PlayStation Store while also taking a 30 percent cut of every sale, resulting in “excessive and unfair prices”.
According to The Game Business, the crux of Neill’s allegations revolved around the idea that buying a PS5 essentially locked a customer into Sony’s ecosystem. However, the UK’s Tribunal disagreed with this, noting that Sony hasn’t really broken any laws regarding a competitive marketplace. Rather, the company has been competing against others like Microsoft and Nintendo. Along with this, the court noted that customers can also choose to buy physical copies of games, avoiding the PlayStation Store entirely.
As part of this ruling, the Tribunal has noted that PlayStation can’t be forced to open its hardware and software up to third-party stores due to how expensive, complicated, and insecure things would get. As for the prices of games being unfair, the court noted that Neill hasn’t provided any evidence that Sony’s profit margins on selling the games have been excessive.
It is worth noting that this is just the lawsuit out of the UK, and that the company still faces other similar legal battles across the world. In June 2025, the company was hit by a lawsuit alleging unfair pricing for digital games by Dutch foundation Mass Damage & Consumer. The foundation has alleged that Sony is abusing its dominant position in the console market and is setting the prices for its hardware and software too high.
“Many people notice that since the latest PS5 generation, they are increasingly being pushed towards ‘digital-only’ consoles,” said Mass Damage & Consumer foundation chairman Lucia Melcherts (via Google Translate). “These consoles work exclusively with digital games instead of physical discs. However, economic research has shown that consumers pay an average of 47% more for those digital versions than for the exact same game on a physical disc, while the distribution costs for Sony are lower.”
“The fact that Sony dares to go up by tens of percent without any quid pro quo is telling for what the proportions are. Sony is the only digital content provider on the world’s most popular game console. Of all Dutch people who have a game console at home, more than 80% have a PlayStation. It can now afford to make decisions without having to worry much about what competitors, developers, or consumers are doing.”
The foundation went on to claim that developers have been held back by Sony as well due to the lack of any other digital stores on PlayStation. This means that many important decisions, like the price of games, lie solely in Sony’s hands. “Developers thus lose their freedom to set their own price, but also their negotiating position as a commercial party.”

